Emma Watson - Joan Aiken and Jane Austen

I read 2 books completing Jane Austen's The Watsons, of which she only wrote five chapters. Austen family history relates how she intended the plot to come out, though of course Austen might have changed her mind while writing.

Joan Aiken's effort, Emma Watson, starts after the fragment Austen left, and while keeping the personalities of the characters established by Austen the same, changes the plot considerably. Merryn William's completion, The Watsons, uses the original five chapters and the intended plot where it is known. Her effort is a lot closer to Austen than Aiken's, but the Aiken version is much more fun to read and better written, with more lively language. Although she puts in unusual events, everyone's reactions to them ring very true to their characters.

William's version is worth reading, and is better than nearly all the other Austen efforts I have read, but seems a little flat, being without Austen's gift for the right word and the right incident to show someone's true character. I'll be keeping the Aiken version.

Emma Watson first published 1996, The Watsons 2005

Two books by Ellis Peters

Fallen into the Pit is a detective novel set just after World War II. The author is trying to portray the tensions in the changing society and the emotional aftermath of the war for the people who fought and came home, which is all quite interesting. However to modern readers what is most striking is the children regularly playing unsupervised for hours in an area full of mine shafts. This book gives the definite impression modern children are over-protected physically, though the parent's concerns about manners and obedience and bad influences seem timeless. As soon as the second person died I guessed who had done all the murders and why, usually I have no idea whodunnit. An interesting and recommended book on the whole, though a few too many coincidences.

The Horn of Roland is not recommended unless you are a romantic who can believe six impossible things before breakfast. Like a person who has taken on their mother's vendetta so completely they try to kill a person over something that happened when they themselves were a baby is not mentally ill, but an otherwise normal person. And that a musician/composer has a daughter who does not play a musical instrument. Again, the villain is fairly obvious.

Fallen into the Pit first published 1951, The Horn of Roland 1974

Monette, McCrumb and Goudge

Foggy Mountain Breakdown by Sharon McCrumb is a collection of short stories, and well worth reading. The first story is very striking, and there is a Rattler story for Rattler fans, but no Norah Bonesteel, alas. There are Appalachian stories and straight detective stories, and humorous stories too. A few stories are not that interesting, in the usual way of collections.

Don't read Melusine by Sarah Monette unless you like detailed accounts of pain, anguish, betrayal, and violent sex. And other horrible events and people, though some of them can't help themselves because of their dreadful past, or at least that's the excuse. I only managed a few chapters before giving up, though I did check out the end. I requested this book at the library because I read a favourable review, but was doubtful as soon as I saw it. Pretty boy covers rarely presage books I enjoy.

Immediate Family by Eileen Goudge starts with four friends at a college reunion, aged 36, all with sufficient money and fulfilling enough jobs to give lots of attention to their not very interesting emotional lives. One is married, one is divorced with a child, one has a boyfriend and the single one decides to have a child without a partner. By the end of the book there has been one divorce and one healthy baby, two breakups and two deaths (a parent and a still born child), one father found and three weddings - I probably missed a few other events in this action packed 18 months as I got bored and skipped more than half the book. This book reminded me why I so rarely read straight romances (as in books where the whole focus is on finding a bloke to sweep you off your feet).

Foggy Mountain Breakdown first published 1998, Melusine in 2005, Immediate Family in 2006.

We'll Meet Again by Hilary Green

This a pleasant enough book, if you have nothing better to read. It is set during World War II, and finding out about the people who did the radio communication and coding of messages for and from agents behind enemy lines was quite interesting, as were the characters. I found the events of the last quarter a bit unrealistic - the main character seems rather good at persuading higher authority to do things her way - which reduced my enjoyment of the book.

We'll Meet Again first published 2005

Mystic and Rider by Sharon Shinn

Sharon Shinn is always interesting to read, though sometimes I don't like her endings. She does very interesting societies and characters, and her villains are real people too. But in spite of there nearly always being a political plot line, she writes the climax of the novel as the climax of the romance plot line, which is occasionally not strong enough for the book as a whole. (I'm thinking of Wrapt in Crystal here)

So I read this one and was fascinated as usual by her story, but a bit apprehensive about the ending. However, it was quite satisfactory, as this is part of a series, so the romance bit ended this book nicely with the political plot line obviously to be continued in next volume. This was a good strong fantasy novel, as in enjoyable and well thought out rather than anything strikingly new, highly recommended if you like fantasy or romance.

Mystic and Rider first published 2005

Lost Children by Edith Pargeter

This is in some ways typical of a British post-WWII novel, containing a cross-class romance and friendships and social comment, both on class and on the acute shortage of housing in the post war period. It wasn't earnest and polemical about it though, and I enjoyed this book.

The style is a little stilted and wordy occasionally, but I liked the people, and the way there were four main characters and their interactions. I also liked how the novel left their history going on, some problems are solved or at least become manageable and some don't, like life.

The romance was only part of the plot. The title refers to the isolated family situation of several of the characters, the four main are all effectively motherless, and one is illegitimate. You can see the times changing, he is still presented as a sympathetic character!

Lost Children first published 1951

Stan Lee, Smith and Colfer

We'll go from best to worst here. Alexa is a comic book (or graphic novel if you are under 35), I read the first 3 episodes, and it was quite interesting till the last few pages of episode 3 where it went all obvious and ordinary. Though perhaps I should mention this is the first graphic novel I have read in 20 years or so. Alexa is a comic book artist who objects to the normal depiction of females in graphic novels by wearing skintight jeans and skivvy. This comic is drawn by males, what a surprise.

Behold, a Mystery! by Joan Smith is a Regency romance cum mystery, quite competent (usually they are abysmal) though I skipped a few boring bits. I was only mildly interested in who done it and who the heroine would marry.

The Wish List by Eoin Colfer had a strange view of goodness, in fact a perfectly pukable view of goodness. The heroine's good deeds and bad deeds are perfectly balanced when she dies (this Ancient Egyptian theology is presented as Christian, the Pope and Martin Luther are both sobbing into their soup) so she is sent back to overbalance the scale one way or the other, by helping someone else achieve their wishes. A kiss in a television studio between two elderly people who regret not kissing in their youth is described as a moment of pure goodness (getting there has needed some deception and manipulation), complete with ethereal light. On the other hand, what seemed to me truly a moment of pure goodness later in the book, where someone asks for and receives forgiveness, in the ordinary difficult way, passed without such light. I have not read a decent story ever about someone coming back after death to fix things, they are all revoltingly sentimental at the least.

Alexa (story by Stan Lee words by Steven Roman, pictures by 8 blokes and 3 women, the women did the colouring in and the lettering) first published 2005; Behold a Mystery! first published 1994, The Wish List first published 2000.

Friend of My Heart by Judith Clarke

This short book has the slightest of plots and the strongest of themes. I read it every few years, and sometimes pick it up to just read a few pages for the humour, and the astonishing way the author manages to tell us something about every character's attitude to love or who they love. Just about every type of love is covered here from several angles, hopeless, happy, contented or mistaken, parents and children, romantic, friends, siblings. Read this delightful book!

Friend of My Heart first published 1994

Other, Luckett, and Flint

I borrowed a book called The Delaney Christmas Carol from the library, thinking it would be an updated version of Dickens. It was three novellas by three authors, each story being a romance; unfortunately the boring sort where at least one person is very rich, both people are exceptionally beautiful, and an overwhelming feeling of mutual lust is a sure sign you are soul mates. The past, present and future were all astonishingly similar. I tried each story but didn't manage to finish any. Avoid this book.

More fun was a re-reading of Dave Luckett's The Truth About Magic and The Return of Rathalorn, fantasy books for children with a good story and good characterisation - both the heroes and the villains have entirely understandable motivations. You can see a whole workable, even if not always admirable, society in the background. An excellent introduction to class, prejudice, and standing up for the right without wrecking your society or yourself. I also thoroughly recommend his Tenabran trilogy for adults.

I also read An Oblique Approach (free in Baen's online library) by David Drake and Eric Flint, which is an alternate history, Byzantium sixth century. A couple of "computers" have popped back in time to change history. A fun light read, and I enjoyed looking up to see which characters were historical (answer lots, who'd have thought we know so much about the sixth century), though way too many people are excellent at their jobs and repartee as well. Style is a bit variable.


A Delaney Christmas Carol first published 2004, The Truth About Magic 2005, The Return of Rathalorn 2005, An Oblique Approach 1998

Fast Women by Jennifer Crusie

This novel is set in a detective agency and has two dead bodies and missing people and missing diamonds. However it reads like romance, or maybe chick lit, so is a light fun read, and gets good marks on the style and plot. Characterisation not so hot - most characters were defined by one or two quirks. I kept losing track of which character was which in the pool of potential villains and who they are or were married to, but got them sorted out in time for the denouement.

The dialogue is pretty good, and the musings on relationships are higher quality than most romance/chick lit books - which isn't saying much I know! I borrowed this from the library, having seen Crusie's name recommended.

Fast Women first published 2001 -why it is called that I can't imagine.